Who Gets to Define Patriotism?

The Paradox branded artwork with three Black military figures, including a woman, an American flag, broken chains, and a bridge. The banner reads Born in the Crucible of Struggle.

Black military service and the right to speak honestly about the nation

Episode 2 is now available. Watch “Who Gets to Define Patriotism?” — Andre Smith, Part One. You can also read this companion essay on Substack.

In 1991, I was the only Black sailor in a Navy office when our executive officer walked in with a man wearing a Los Angeles County Sheriff’s uniform. My executive officer looked toward me and said, “There he is, get him.” I froze. Then the men around me began to laugh.

The visitor was the officer’s brother, there on a personal visit. No one had come to arrest me. Yet the joke had placed me in the role of a Black man being pursued by the police. Against the backdrop of the televised beating of Rodney King, my fear was immediate. My uniform had not prevented the encounter. Neither had the fact that I was simply there doing my job.1,2

I carried that memory for years without having a ready way to explain it. I had served my country and taken pride in doing so. I had also learned that being part of a military institution did not settle every question about where I belonged. Those experiences occupied the same life.

They lead me to a question that reaches beyond the military: who gets to define patriotism? A country can praise someone’s contribution while resisting what that person has learned about it. An inclusive patriotism must allow people to judge the institutions they serve and give their knowledge a meaningful part in changing them.

The person inside the uniform

My investment in military service began at home. My father was an Air Force medic, and I remember the pride of waiting to see him return in his white scrubs. Later, growing up in Gary, Indiana, I watched steel jobs disappear and downtown stores close. When I joined the Navy in 1984, I wanted to serve. I also wanted a way to leave Gary and pay for college. Family pride and practical need belonged to the same decision.

Andre Smith, who entered the Air Force in 2007, described a different beginning when he spoke with me about his service. He needed income, educational support, and a workable way to meet his responsibilities. He called the institution “a tool, not a family.” He also expressed attachment to the United States and a desire to see it change. His practical reasons for enlisting did not fully explain his relationship to the country, any more than my childhood pride fully explained mine.1

A uniform cannot tell us everything about the person wearing it. It does not establish support for every war or agreement with every leader. It cannot determine whether someone accepts the word patriotic. When we prescribe what service must mean, we make it harder to hear what an individual actually believes.

The familiar public image of the service member can narrow that hearing further. In my work, I use the phrase “white male warrior archetype” to examine a cultural expectation: whiteness and masculinity become the assumed features of the authentic military figure. When that picture becomes a standard for judging others, people outside it can find themselves repeatedly establishing a belonging that others are allowed to assume.1,5

This is a question about how authority is assigned, not a description of how every white man behaves. People can reinforce the expectation, question it, or help change it. The consequence becomes visible when someone’s account of service is treated as suspect because it unsettles the familiar picture.

What rank cannot guarantee

Andre’s experience in Charleston shows why an organizational chart cannot answer every question about authority. In March 2021, he was beginning his duties as a security forces flight chief. A civilian counterpart was driving him around the base. Andre held the senior position in their working relationship; the other man had worked there for years.

According to Andre, their introductory conversation turned toward George Floyd’s killing. He tried to redirect it toward the base tour. The man persisted, eventually saying that Floyd had received what he deserved and that he would have acted similarly. Andre was now considering how to respond to someone he would have to work beside. This encounter preceded Derek Chauvin’s conviction for second-degree murder.1,3

Andre knew the man was established in the unit. He did not know the extent of his connections. That uncertainty mattered. A newcomer can know where he stands in the formal chain of responsibility while knowing very little about whose objections will be supported, whose conduct will be excused, or how a dispute will travel through the workplace.

Andre eventually challenged the appropriateness of having that conversation with the new Black master sergeant for whom the man worked. He had to decide how to respond before he could know how his objection would be received. His official position did not remove that uncertainty.

The larger question is whether people can use the authority they formally possess when their judgment challenges an established colleague. Titles and appointments matter. So do the less visible conditions that make it possible to question conduct, seek support, and expect a fair response. We cannot infer those conditions from rank alone.

The responsibility to listen

After my own encounter in the Navy office, I had no senior Black mentor in my chain of command to whom I could turn. I lacked both a trusted person to help me interpret what had happened and the language to explain why it had stayed with me. The experience did not become less real because I could not immediately give a clear account of it.

Andre’s earlier experience in Turkey offers a useful comparison. He was stationed there when George Floyd was killed in Minneapolis on May 25, 2020. Younger Black service members turned to him with anger and uncertainty. Far from the communities they cared about during the pandemic, they were confronting news that broke through the sense of separation military life had sometimes provided.1,3

He also described worthwhile conversations with a white commander about racism and the need to discuss it without waiting for a national crisis. Andre distinguished some colleagues’ uncertainty about what to say from hostility. The commander’s willingness to engage mattered to him.

Such encounters raise a practical question for institutions: how can support become dependable? A sympathetic leader can make a considerable difference, but people also need ways to raise concerns when that person is absent, transferred, or unwilling to listen. The possibility of being heard should not rest entirely on a fortunate relationship.

Philosopher Miranda Fricker calls one obstacle “testimonial injustice.” It occurs when prejudice causes a listener to give a speaker less credibility than the speaker deserves. Put plainly, assumptions about a person can obstruct our understanding of what that person knows. A speaker labeled angry, oversensitive, or insufficiently loyal may find that the label has settled the matter before the evidence receives attention.4

A fair hearing does not require automatic agreement. People can misremember, disagree, or draw different conclusions from the same event. It requires that a judgment rest on the account and the available evidence, with a real opportunity to explain and challenge a decision. The listener’s discomfort is not a sound reason to close the inquiry.

I developed Black Veteranality to examine how Black life and military service produce knowledge about the nation, and how racial power shapes the authority that knowledge receives. Veterans’ experiences can reveal features of institutions that their official descriptions leave out. Their knowledge exists before an institution acknowledges it; acknowledgment alone does not ensure that it will affect a decision.5

This is where listening becomes a responsibility to act. An organization can thank someone for speaking and continue exactly as before. A meaningful response requires those responsible to examine the evidence, explain their judgment, and address what it warrants. Where harm is established, that may mean correcting a practice, providing a remedy, or protecting the person who raised the concern from retaliation.

The response must also be open to challenge. A person should have somewhere to turn when the immediate supervisor is part of the problem. An independent review can matter as much as a welcoming conversation. Keeping a record of the concern and its resolution can help the institution learn instead of requiring the next person to begin again. These are practical ways to give testimony consequences.

A country open to correction

The insistence that service can sharpen a demand for justice has a long history. In his May 1919 editorial “Returning Soldiers,” W. E. B. Du Bois urged Black veterans returning from World War I to continue the struggle for democracy at home. Near the end, he declared: “We return. We return from fighting. We return fighting.”6

Du Bois refused to let military service close the question of the country’s obligations. Returning veterans had grounds to judge the democracy they had been called to defend. His words remain useful because they make room for a relationship in which contribution and criticism belong together. They do not require us to believe that every veteran shared his convictions or that every war deserved support.

There is another limit to observe. Calling every criticism patriotic would again allow someone else to decide what a person’s actions mean. Some veterans embrace the word. Some qualify it. Others refuse it. Respect for their service includes respect for their authority to describe their own relationship to the country.

My own commitment is to a patriotism constrained by equal dignity, justice, and responsibility for repair. That commitment includes the freedom to disagree with me about patriotism itself. A person should be able to question the nation’s conduct without first performing a prescribed attachment to it.

Military service is fundamental to my perspective, but it is not the price of anyone’s rights. People who have never served have the same claim to dignity, safety, and a fair hearing. Neither a uniform nor a patriotic declaration makes one person’s humanity more important than another’s. A democracy must remain answerable to people across those differences.

Being answerable requires more than invitations to speak. People need effective ways to challenge decisions, organize with others, obtain remedies, and change who governs. Their experiences must be able to alter the questions institutions ask and the choices they make. Otherwise, inclusion can leave people no better able to influence decisions.

I think again of that Navy office, of my fear while others laughed. A truthful account of my service has to include that moment alongside the pride. Neither can be understood by requiring the other to disappear. The same is true of a country whose people know it from different positions.

Who gets to define patriotism is therefore a question about who can help the country understand itself and demand that it change. My service gives me experiences from which to speak. Equal dignity gives me standing to be heard. A defensible patriotism must leave room for that knowledge to change how the nation acts.

More from the author

Winner of the 2026 Senators Bob and Elizabeth Dole Biennial Award for Distinguished Book in Veterans Studies.

In my book, Black Veteranality: Military Service and the Illusion of Inclusive Patriotism, I explore how Black veterans understand service, identity, and belonging in a country where military sacrifice and racial exclusion can coexist. Drawing on personal narrative, historical analysis, and veterans’ accounts, I challenge familiar assumptions about patriotism and introduce the Black Veteranality framework. If this essay has raised questions about whose service is recognized and whose experiences are heard, I invite you to read the book and examine what a more inclusive patriotism requires.

Learn more and order from Routledge

Explore the new Born in the Crucible of Struggle t-shirts from The Paradox, available in short-sleeve and long-sleeve styles, in my website store.

Read more essays at drbryonlgarner.org and on Substack. The Paradox: Black Veteran Conversations brings personal accounts into a continuing examination of race, patriotism, and national identity.

© 2026 Bryon L. Garner. The Paradox: Black Veteran Conversations.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top